Manchester City’s 17-year-old starter was named ahead of Erling Haaland, who was rested after picking up a knock. Although the youngster had never scored a senior career goal, the video argues that past goals alone are not the right way to estimate his chance of scoring in a particular match.
The method described is:
That produced an estimated 46% chance of him scoring, equivalent to fair decimal odds of about 2.17. Betfair’s closing anytime-scorer price was 2.16. The estimate was close to the market price, even though the player ultimately did not score. One match’s outcome does not by itself show that the probability estimate was wrong.
The first-goalscorer estimate was 5.75, close to Betfair’s 5.8 closing price; earlier prices were reportedly more generous after the lineup news.
Since the start of the season, the service had logged 6,685 exchange closing lines for player expected goals and statistics such as fouls. Reported returns were:
The speaker stresses that this is still a small sample and plans to revisit the results at 20,000 lines. Results should be assessed by the number of games, not just the number of player bets, because many bets can be affected by the same match events.
The video notes that exchange liquidity varies by match and player. As an example, Everton–Chelsea had roughly £104,000 traded on match odds and £109,000 on player shots on target shortly before kickoff. That level of liquidity is not guaranteed across all markets.
The reported results compare models with market closing prices. The speaker says they do not personally place every listed bet, partly because there are too many opportunities and closing-line liquidity is not always available to filter by. Bookie Bashing is described as a data service, not a tipping service.
With team news still several hours away, the speaker says early analysis generally favoured laying rather than backing:
The video also mentions that Bookie Bashing had built an improved lineup tool, including estimated lineups, after finding existing lineup data insufficient.